Human facial and vocal attractiveness： From the multiple signals processing perspective
ZHANG Hang1,2, LI weijun2, ZHANG Jijia1
1 Faculty of Education, Guangxi Normal University, Guilin 514004; 2 Brain and Cognitive Neuroscience Research Center, Liaoning Normal University, Dalian 116029
[1] 陈丽君, 江洁, 任志洪, 袁宏. (2017). “阳刚”还是“清秀”更具吸引力? 对男性面孔二态性不同偏好的元分析.心理科学进展, 25(4), 553-569. [2] 顾吉有, 吕勇. (2016). 选择性注意和分配性注意对多感觉整合的不同影响.心理与行为研究, 14(2), 202-206. [3] 寇慧, 苏艳华, 张妍, 孔繁昌, 胡媛艳, 王洋, 陈红. (2013). 面孔吸引力的影响因素:观察者假设.心理科学进展, 21(12), 2144-2153. [4] 李鸥, 陈红. (2010). 面孔吸引力的回顾与前瞻.心理科学进展, 18(3), 472-479. [5] 刘睿, 王莉, 蒋毅. (2016). 意识与多感觉信息整合的最新研究进展.科学通报, (1), 2-11. [6] 吴宝沛, 吴静, 张雷, 李璐. (2014). 择偶与人类嗓音.心理科学进展, 22(12), 1953-1963. [7] 徐华伟, 牛盾, 李倩. (2016). 面孔吸引力和配偶价值: 进化心理学视角.心理科学进展, 24(7), 1130-1138. [8] 张妍, 孔繁昌, 陈红, 向燕辉, 高笑, 陈敏燕. (2010). 男性对女性面孔吸引力的认知偏好:来自ERP的证据.心理学报, 42(11), 1060-1072. [9] 郑怡, 尚俊辰, 李伯冉, 梁耀文, 何嘉梅, 由一林, 蒋重清. (2017). 人类嗓音吸引力的影响因素.心理科学进展, 25(2), 237-246. [10] 张航. (2019). 情人耳中出西施: 人类嗓音吸引力的认知加工机制及其影响因素. 辽宁师范大学硕士学位论文. [11] Abend P., Pflüger L. S., Koppensteiner M., Coquerelle M., & Grammer K. (2015). The sound of female shape: A redundant signal of vocal and facial attractiveness.Evolution and Human Behavior, 36(3), 174-181. [12] Amodio, D. M., & Frith, C. D. (2006). Meeting of minds: The medial frontal cortex and social cognition.Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 7(4), 268-277. [13] Banks G. C., Batchelor J. H., & McDaniel M. A. (2010). Smarter people are (a bit) more symmetrical: A meta-analysis of the relationship between intelligence and fluctuating asymmetry.Intelligence, 38(4), 393-401. [14] Belin P., Bestelmeyer P. E., Latinus M., & Watson R. (2011). Understanding voice perception.British Journal of Psychology, 102(4), 711-725. [15] Belin P., Zatorre R. J., & Ahad P. (2002). Human temporal-lobe response to vocal sounds.Cognitive Brain Research, 13(1), 17-26. [16] Bestelmeyer P. E., Latinus M., Bruckert L., Rouger J., Crabbe F., & Belin P. (2012). Implicitly perceived vocal attractiveness modulates prefrontal cortex activity.Cerebral Cortex, 22(6), 1263-1270. [17] Bird B. M., Welling L. L. M., Ortiz T. L., Moreau B. J. P., Hansen S., Emond M.,.. Carré J. M. (2016). Effects of exogenous testosterone and mating context on men’s preferences for female facial femininity.Hormones and Behavior, 85, 76-85. [18] Boothroyd L. G., Meins E., Vukovic J., & Burt D. M. (2014). Developmental changes in children’s facial preferences.Evolution and Human Behavior, 35(5), 376-383. [19] Bruckert L., Bestelmeyer P., Latinus M., Rouger J., Charest I., Rousselet G. A.,.. Belin P. (2010). Vocal attractiveness increases by averaging.Current Biology, 20(20), 116-120. [20] Burriss R. P., Marcinkowska U. M., & Lyons M. T. (2014). Gaze properties of women judging the attractiveness of masculine and feminine male faces.Evolutionary Psychology, 12(1), 19-35. [21] Campanella, S., & Belin, P. (2007). Integrating face and voice in person perception.Trends in Cognitive sciences, 11(12), 535-543. [22] Candolin, U. (2003). The use of multiple cues in mate choice.Biological Reviews, 78(4), 575-595. [23] Charest I., Pernet C. R., Rousselet G. A., Qui?ones I., Latinus M., Fillionbilodeau S.,333 Belin P. (2009). Electrophysiological evidence for an early processing of human voices.BMC Neuroscience, 10(1), 127. [24] Chen A. C., German C., & Zaidel D. W. (1997). Brain asymmetry and facial attractiveness: Facial beauty is not simply in the eye of the beholder.Neuropsychologia, 35(4), 471-476. [25] Collins, S. A. (2000). Men's voices and women's choices.Animal Behaviour, 60(6), 773-780. [26] Collins, S. A., & Missing, C. (2003). Vocal and visual attractiveness are related in women.Animal Behaviour, 65(5), 997-1004. [27] Danel D. P., Siennicka A. E., Fedurek P., Frackowiak T., Sorokowski P., Jankowska E. A., & Pawlowski B. (2017). Men with a terminal illness relax their criteria for facial attractiveness.American Journal of Men’s Health, 11(4), 1247-1254. [28] DeBruine, L. M. (2014). Women’s preferences for male facial features. Evolutionary perspectives on human sexual psychology and behavior(pp. 261-275): Springer New York [29] Dion K., Berscheid E., & Walster E. (1972). What is beautiful is good.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 24(3), 285-290. [30] Eisenthal Y., Dror G., & Ruppin E. (2006). Facial attractiveness: Beauty and the machine.Neural Computation, 18(1), 119-142. [31] Ellis, A. W. (1989). Neuro-cognitive processing of faces and voices.Handbook of Research on Face Processing, 207-215. [32] Eysholdt U., Rosanowski F., & Hoppe U. (2003). Vocal fold vibration irregularities caused by different types of laryngeal asymmetry.European Archives of Oto-rhino-laryngology, 260(8), 412-417. [33] Feinberg D., Jones B., DeBruine L., O’connor J., Tigue C., & Borak D. (2011). Integrating fundamental and formant frequencies in women’s preferences for men’s voices.Behavioral Ecology, 22(6), 1320-1325. [34] Feinberg D. R., DeBruine L. M., Jones B. C., & Perrett D. I. (2008a). The role of femininity and averageness of voice pitch in aesthetic judgments of women's voices.Perception, 37(4), 615-623. [35] Feinberg D. R., DeBruine L. M., Jones B. C., & Little A. C. (2008b). Correlated preferences for men's facial and vocal masculinity.Evolution and Human Behavior, 29(4), 233-241. [36] Feinberg D. R., Jones B. C., Little A. C., Burt D. M., & Perrett D. I. (2005). Manipulations of fundamental and formant frequencies influence the attractiveness of human male voices.Animal Behaviour, 69(3), 561-568. [37] Feinberg D. R., Jones B. C., Smith M. L., Moore F. R., DeBruine L. M., Cornwell R.,.. Perrett D. (2006). Menstrual cycle, trait estrogen level, and masculinity preferences in the human voice.Hormones and Behavior, 49(2), 215-222. [38] Ferdenzi C., Delplanque S., Atanassova R., & Sander D. (2016). Androstadienone's influence on the perception of facial and vocal attractiveness is not sex specific.Psychoneuroendocrinology, 66, 166-175. [39] Fink B., Grammer K., & Thornhill R. (2001). Human (Homo sapiens) facial attractiveness in relation to skin texture and color.Journal of Comparative Psychology, 115(1), 92-99. [40] Foo Y. Z., Simmons L. W., & Rhodes G. (2017). Predictors of facial attractiveness and health in humans.Scientific Reports, 7, 39731. [41] Fraccaro P. J., Jones B. C., Vukovic J., Smith F. G., Watkins C. D., Feinberg D. R.,.. Debruine L. M. (2011). Experimental evidence that women speak in a higher voice pitch to men they find attractive.Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, 9(1), 57-67. [42] Fraccaro P. J., O’Connor J. J., Re D. E., Jones B. C., DeBruine L. M., & Feinberg D. R. (2013). Faking it: Deliberately altered voice pitch and vocal attractiveness.Animal Behaviour, 85(1), 127-136. [43] Franklin, R. G., & Adams, R. B. (2009). A dual-process account of female facial attractiveness preferences: Sexual and nonsexual routes.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 45(5), 1156-1159. [44] Galton, F. (1878). Composite portraits. Nature, 18, 97-100. [45] Gangestad, S. W., & Simpson, J. A. (2000). The evolution of human mating: Trade-offs and strategic pluralism.Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 23(04), 573-587. [46] Germine L., Russell R., Bronstad P. M., Blokland G. A., Smoller J. W., Kwok H.,.. Wilmer J. B. (2015). Individual aesthetic preferences for faces are shaped mostly by environments, not genes.Current Biology, 25(20), 2684-2689. [47] Harris, C. R. (2011). Menstrual cycle and facial preferences reconsidered.Sex Roles, 64(9), 669. [48] Harris, L. T., & Fiske, S. T. (2010). Neural regions that underlie reinforcement learning are also active for social expectancy violations.Social Neuroscience, 5(1), 76-91. [49] Hensel L., Bzdok D., Müller V. I., Zilles K., & Eickhoff S. B. (2015). Neural correlates of explicit social judgments on vocal stimuli.Cerebral Cortex, 25(5), 1152-1162. [50] Hill A. K.,& Puts, D. A. (2016). Vocal attractiveness. Encyclopedia of evolutionary psychological science, eds V. Weekes-Shackelford, TK Shackelford, and VA Weekes-Shackelford(Cham: Springer International Publishing), 1-5. [51] Hill A. K., Cárdenas R. A., Wheatley J. R., Welling L. L. M., Burriss R. P., Claes P.,.. Shriver M. D. (2017a). Are there vocal cues to human developmental stability? Relationships between facial fluctuating asymmetry and voice attractiveness.Evolution and Human Behavior, 38, 249-258. [52] Hill A. K., Bailey D. H., & Puts D. A. (2017b). Gorillas in our midst? Human sexual dimorphism and contest competition in men. On Human Nature (pp. 235-249). [53] Hodges-Simeon C. R., Gaulin S. J., & Puts D. A. (2010). Different vocal parameters predict perceptions of dominance and attractiveness.Human Nature: An Interdisciplinary Biosocial Perspective, 21(4), 406-427. [54] Hughes, S. M., & Miller, N. E. (2015). What sounds beautiful looks beautiful stereotype: The matching of attractiveness of voices and faces.Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 33, 984-996. [55] Hughes S. M., Pastizzo M. J., & Jr, G. G. G. (2008). The sound of symmetry revisited: Subjective and objective analyses of voice.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 32(2), 93-108. [56] Itier, R. J., & Taylor, M. J. (2004). Source analysis of the N170 to faces and objects.Neuroreport, 15(8), 1261-1265. [57] Jones B. C., Feinberg D. R., DeBruine L. M., Little A. C., & Vukovic J. (2010). A domain-specific opposite-sex bias in human preferences for manipulated voice pitch.Animal Behaviour, 79(1), 57-62. [58] Jones B. C., Feinberg D. R., Watkins C. D., Fincher C. L., Little A. C., & Debruine L. M. (2013). Pathogen disgust predicts women’s preferences for masculinity in men’s voices, faces, and bodies.Behavioral Ecology, 24(2), 373-379. [59] Jones, D., & Hill, K. (1993). Criteria of facial attractiveness in five populations.Human Nature, 4(3), 271-296. [60] Kandrik M., Hahn A. C., Wincenciak J., Fisher C. I., Pisanski K., Feinberg D. R.,.. Jones B. C. (2016). Are men’s perceptions of sexually dimorphic vocal characteristics related to their testosterone levels?PloS One, 11(11), e0166855. [61] Kanwisher, N., & Yovel, G. (2011). The fusiform face area: A cortical region specialized for the perception of faces.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 361(1476), 2109-2128. [62] Karwowski M., Puts D., Roberts S. C., & Sorokowski P. (2017). Attractiveness is multimodal: Beauty is also in the nose and ear of the beholder.Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 778. [63] Komori M., Kawamura S., & Ishihara S. (2009). Effect of averageness and sexual dimorphism on the judgment of facial attractiveness.Vision Research, 49(8), 862-869. [64] Lander, K. (2008). Relating visual and vocal attractiveness for moving and static faces.Animal Behaviour, 75(3), 817-822. [65] Langlois, J. H., & Roggman, L. A. (1990). Attractive faces are only average.Psychological Science, 1(2), 115-121. [66] Latinus M., Mcaleer P., Bestelmeyer P. E. G., & Belin P. (2013). Norm-based coding of voice identity in human auditory cortex.Current Biology, 23(12), 1075-1080. [67] Lee A. J., Mitchem D. G., Wright M. J., Martin N. G., Keller M. C., & Zietsch B. P. (2016). Facial averageness and genetic quality: Testing heritability, genetic correlation with attractiveness, and the paternal age effect.Evolution and Human Behavior, 37(1), 61-66. [68] Little, A. C. (2008). Symmetry and sexual dimorphism in human faces: Interrelated preferences suggest both signal quality.Behavioral Ecology, 19(4), 902-908. [69] Little, A. C. (2014). Facial attractiveness.Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 5(6), 621-634. [70] Little A. C., Cohen D. L., Jones B. C., & Belsky J. (2007a). Human preferences for facial masculinity change with relationship type and environmental harshness.Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 61(6), 967-973. [71] Little A. C., Apicella C. L., & Marlowe F. W. (2007b). Preferences for symmetry in human faces in two cultures: Data from the UK and the Hadza, an isolated group of hunter-gatherers.Proceedings Biological Sciences, 274(1629), 3113-3117. [72] Little A. C., Connely J., Feinberg D. R., Jones B. C., & Roberts S. C. (2011a). Human preference for masculinity differs according to context in faces, bodies, voices, and smell.Behavioral Ecology, 22(4), 862-868. [73] Little A. C., Jones B. C., & Debruine L. M. (2011b). Facial attractiveness: Evolutionary based research.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 366(1571), 1638-1659. [74] Little A. C., Jones B. C., Feinberg D. R., & Perrett D. I. (2014). Men’s strategic preferences for femininity in female faces.British Journal of Psychology, 105(3), 364-381. [75] Little A. C., Jones B. C., Penton-Voak I. S., Burt D. M., & Perrett D. I. (2002). Partnership status and the temporal context of relationships influence human female preferences for sexual dimorphism in male face shape.Royal Society Proceedings B Biological Sciences, 269(1496), 1095-1100. [76] Lu H. J., Zhu X. Q., & Chang L. (2015). Good genes, good providers, and good fathers: Economic development involved in how women select a mate.Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences, 9, 215-228. [77] Maestripieri D., Henry A., & Nickels N. (2017). Explaining financial and prosocial biases in favor of attractive people: Interdisciplinary perspectives from economics, social psychology, and evolutionary psychology.Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 40. [78] Mcgurk, H., & Macdonald, J. (1976). Hearing lips and seeing voices. Nature, 264(5588), 746. [79] Morton, E. S. (1977). On the occurrence and significance of motivation-structural rules in some bird and mammal sounds.The American Naturalist, 111(981), 855-869. [80] Munoz, N. E., & Blumstein, D. T. (2012). Multisensory perception in uncertain environments.Behavioral Ecology, 23(3), 457-462. [81] O’Connor J. J., Re D. E., & Feinberg D. R. (2011). Voice pitch influences perceptions of sexual infidelity.Evolutionary Psychology, 9(1), 64-78. [82] O’Doherty J., Winston J., Critchley H., Perrett D., Burt D. M., & Dolan R. J. (2003). Beauty in a smile: The role of medial orbitofrontal cortex in facial attractiveness.Neuropsychologia, 41(2), 147-155. [83] O’Connor J. J. M., Feinberg D. R., Fraccaro P. J., Borak D. J., Tigue C. C., Re D. E.,.. Tiddeman B. (2012). Female preferences for male vocal and facial masculinity in videos.Ethology, 118(4), 321-330. [84] Oppenheimer, D. M. (2008). The secret life of fluency.Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 12(6), 237-241. [85] Partan, S., & Marler, P. (1999). Communication goes multimodal.Science, 283(5406), 1272-1273. [86] Penton-Voak I. S., Perrett D. I., Castles D. L., Kobayashi T., Burt D. M., Murray L. K., & Minamisawa R.(1999). Menstrual cycle alters face preference.Nature, 399(6738), 741-742. [87] Pentonvoak, I. S., & Chen, J. Y. (2004). High salivary testosterone is linked to masculine male facial appearance in humans.Evolution and Human Behavior, 25(4), 229-241. [88] Perrett D. I., May K. A., & Yoshikawa S. (1994). Facial shape and judgments of female attractiveness.Nature, 368(6468), 239-242. [89] Petkov, Christopher I., & Vuong, Quoc C. (2013). Neuronal coding: The value in having an average voice.Current Biology, 23(12), R521-R523. [90] Puts D. A., Barndt J. L., Welling L. L., Dawood K., & Burriss R. P. (2011). Intrasexual competition among women: Vocal femininity affects perceptions of attractiveness and flirtatiousness.Personality and Individual Differences, 50(1), 111-115. [91] Puts D. A., Hill A. K., Bailey D. H., Walker R. S., Rendall D., Wheatley J. R.,.. Burriss R. P. (2016). Sexual selection on male vocal fundamental frequency in humans and other anthropoids.Proceedings Biological Sciences, 283(1829). [92] Re D. E., O'Connor J. J., Bennett P. J., & Feinberg D. R. (2012). Preferences for very low and very high voice pitch in humans.PLoS One, 7(3), e32719. [93] Rezlescu C., Penton T., Walsh V., Tsujimura H., Scott S. K., & Banissy M. J. (2015). Dominant voices and attractive faces: The contribution of visual and auditory information to integrated person impressions.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 39(4), 1-16. [94] Rhodes, G. (2006). The evolutionary psychology of facial beauty.Annual Review of Psychology, 57, 199-226. [95] Rhodes G., Hickford C., & Jeffery L. (2000). Sex-typicality and attractiveness: Are supermale and superfemale faces super-attractive.British Journal of Psychology, 91(1), 125-140. [96] Roberts S. C., Kralevich A., Ferdenzi C., Saxton T. K., Jones B. C., Debruine L. M.,.. Havlicek J. (2011). Body odor quality predicts behavioral attractiveness in humans.Archives of Sexual Behavior, 40(6), 1111-1117. [97] Rubenstein A. J., Kalakanis L., & Langlois J. H. (1999). Infant preferences for attractive faces: A cognitive explanation.Developmental Psychology, 35(3), 848-855. [98] Russell, R. (2003). Sex, beauty, and the relative luminance of facial features.Perception, 32(9), 1093-1107. [99] Schirmer, A., & Kotz, S. A. (2006). Beyond the right hemisphere: Brain mechanisms mediating vocal emotional processing.Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 10(1), 24-30. [100] Scott I. M., Clark A. P., Josephson S. C., Boyette A. H., Cuthill I. C., Fried R. L.,.. Jankowiak W. (2014). Human preferences for sexually dimorphic faces may be evolutionarily novel.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(40), 14388-14393. [101] Scott, I. M., & Penton-Voak, I. S. (2011). The validity of composite photographs for assessing masculinity preferences.Perception, 40(3), 323-331. [102] Smith F. G., Jones B. C., & Debruine L. M. (2010). Individual differences in empathizing and systemizing predict variation in face preferences.Personality & Individual Differences, 49(6), 655-658. [103] Smith M. J. L., Perrett D. I., Jones B. C., Cornwell R. E., Moore F. R., Feinberg D. R.,.. Whiten S. (2006). Facial appearance is a cue to oestrogen levels in women.Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B Biological Sciences, 273(1583), 135-140. [104] Thornhill, R., & Gangestad, S. W. (1999). The scent of symmetry : A human sex pheromone that signals fitness?Evolution and Human Behavior, 20(3), 175-201. [105] Thornhill, R., & Mϕller, A. P. (1997). Developmental stability, disease and medicine.Biological Reviews, 72(4), 497-548. [106] Valentine, T. (1991). A unified account of the effects of distinctiveness, inversion, and race in face recognition.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A, 43(2), 161-204. [107] Valentova J. V., Varella M. A. C., Havlí?ek J., & Kleisner K. (2016). Positive association between vocal and facial attractiveness in women but not in men: A cross-cultural study.Behavioural Processes, 135, 95-100. [108] Welling L. L., Jones B. C., DeBruine L. M., Smith F. G., Feinberg D. R., Little A. C., & Al-Dujaili E. A. (2008). Men report stronger attraction to femininity in women’s faces when their testosterone levels are high.Hormones and Behavior, 54(5), 703-708. [109] Wells T., Baguley T., Sergeant M., & Dunn A. (2013). Perceptions of human attractiveness comprising face and voice cues.Archives of Sexual Behavior, 42(5), 805-811. [110] Wells T., Dunn A., Sergeant M., & Davies M. (2009). Multiple signals in human mate selection: A review and framework for integrating facial and vocal signals.Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, 7(2), 111-139. [111] Werheid K., Schacht A., & Sommer W. (2007). Facial attractiveness modulates early and late event-related brain potentials.Biological Psychology, 76(2), 100-108. [112] Wheatley J. R., Apicella C. A., Burriss R. P., Cárdenas R. A., Bailey D. H., Welling L. L., & Puts D. A. (2014). Women’s faces and voices are cues to reproductive potential in industrial and forager societies.Evolution and Human Behavior, 35(4), 264-271. [113] Winkielman P., Halberstadt J., Fazendeiro T., & Catty S. (2006). Prototypes are attractive because they are easy on the mind.Psychological Science, 17(9), 799-806. [114] Xu Y., Lee A., Wu W.-L., Liu X., & Birkholz P. (2013). Human vocal attractiveness as signaled by body size projection.PloS One, 8(4), e62397. [115] Yovel, G., & Belin, P. (2013). A unified coding strategy for processing faces and voices.Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 17(6), 263-271. [116] Zaidel, D. W., & Hessamian, M. (2010). Asymmetry and symmetry in the beauty of human faces.Symmetry, 2(1), 136-149. [117] Zebrowitz L. A., Wang R., Bronstad P. M., Eisenberg D., Undurraga E., Reyes-García V., & Godoy R. (2012). First impressions from faces among US and culturally isolated Tsimane’people in the Bolivian rainforest.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 43(1), 119-134. [118] Zhang H., Liu M., Li W., & Sommer W. (2020). Human voice attractiveness processing: Electrophysiological evidence.Biological Psychology, 150, 107827. [119] Zuckerman, M., & Driver, R. E. (1989). What sounds beautiful is good: The vocal attractiveness stereotype.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 13(2), 67-82.
